- Professional
- Office in Waukesha
If growing people, fixing processes, and embracing change sound like your jam — we should talk.
Now Hiring: Insurance Service Supervisor (a.k.a. Coach, Cheerleader & Change Agent)
Are you the type who loves helping people “get it” for the first time? Do you secretly enjoy untangling processes, spotting inefficiencies, and making things run smoother than a brand-new stapler? Then we’ve got the role for you.
We’re looking for an Insurance Service Supervisor to guide our entry-level team in the commercial division. You’ll be part mentor, part trainer, part efficiency ninja — helping new-to-insurance folks build confidence, grow their skills, and actually enjoy learning the ropes (yes, it can happen).
What you’ll do:
- Grow rookies into rising insurance rockstars.
- Teach processes without boring people to tears.
- Adapt your coaching to different learning styles (because one size doesn’t fit all).
- Embrace change like it’s your favorite coworker.
- Build relationships (internally and with third-party vendors).
- Find better, faster, smarter ways to get things done.
- Have the occasional tough convo with producers — and live to tell the tale.
What we’re looking for:
- 3–5 years of P&C insurance experience.
- A natural leader who loves mentoring (and can laugh while doing it).
- Tech-savvy, customer-service focused, and change-positive.
- Someone who can balance “supportive coach” with “gets things done”.
Why join us:
- A family-friendly environment that’s just as warm as it sounds.
- Competitive salary, benefits and an endless supply of coffee and flavored water.
- Opportunities for growth and development, including learning new skills (and maybe even mastering the art of turning insurance jargon into plain English).
- A team that actually works together – really, we promise it’s not a cult (just a crew that’s stronger together).
If you’re ready to lead a team, drive improvements, and sprinkle a little fun into the world of insurance service, we’d love to meet you.
Apply Now
