Auto & Casualty Claims Adjuster (In-Office) – Sandy Draper, UT bei Stillwater Insurance Group

Join our collaborative team where effort and work ethic get noticed. Enjoy a positive, friendly, energetic work environment with accessible leadership, where you will have the opportunity to learn the insurance industry and valuable skills while we invest in your future career with us.

About Stillwater Insurance Group

Stillwater Insurance Group is a mid-sized national insurance provider offering a variety of home, auto, and commercial insurance products in all 50 states. Headquartered in Jacksonville, Florida, with additional offices in New York and Omaha, Nebraska, we pride ourselves on an upbeat and supportive environment.

We value positive attitudes, reliability, attention to detail, and a passion for learning. Our team enjoys coaching, development, recognition, and growth opportunities—all in a tight-knit setting where honesty and integrity are the foundation of how we work.

Position Summary

We are seeking a mid- to senior-level Auto and Casualty Claims Adjuster to join our in-office team in Sandy Draper, UT. This full-time position is responsible for investigating, measuring, applying coverage, adjusting, and resolving all facets of automobile, homeowner, dwelling, condominium, renters, and commercial casualty insurance claims across Stillwater’s 50-state market.

While this role is principally in-office, occasional travel may be necessary for field investigations, settlement conferences, and mediations. The ideal candidate will bring 5+ years of experience in casualty claims handling, strong analytical skills, and the ability to resolve complex liability matters effectively and professionally.

Key Responsibilities

• Investigate and determine coverage across a variety of casualty claims under residential and commercial policy forms.

• Analyze claim facts and policy language to assess coverage accurately.

• Address and resolve open coverage questions promptly while preserving the company’s legal rights.

• Write original correspondence, including reservation of rights letters, disclaimers, and settlement communications.

• Communicate professionally with all involved parties; return all calls within one hour.

• Use strategic judgment to assign and manage outside resources when appropriate (e.g., independent adjusters, photo apps, legal vendors).

• Set and adjust reserves appropriately based on claim facts, documentation, and anticipated development.

• Conduct detailed scene investigations, gather necessary documents and expert input, and supervise external vendors as needed.

• Document all coverage, liability, and damage analysis clearly and thoroughly in the claim file.

• Identify fraud indicators and refer to SIU when appropriate; collaborate closely with SIU investigators.

• Identify and pursue subrogation and salvage opportunities.

• Navigate complex coverage, AOBs, CRNs, NOIs, and other legal and compliance-related issues.

• Handle bodily injury evaluations, projecting settlement and verdict ranges.

• Develop and implement litigation action plans that align with company strategy and cost-efficiency goals.

• Negotiate settlements directly with claimants, attorneys, and other parties, prioritizing resolution over litigation where appropriate.

• Prepare timely and accurate claim narrative reports for internal management and reinsurers.

• Ensure regulatory and company standards are consistently met in claim handling and documentation.

• Participate in field inspections, on-site meetings, and special projects as required.

• Support after-hours claim support rotation as needed.

• Maintain required adjuster licenses and complete continuing education in accordance with state requirements.

Minimum Qualifications

• Bachelor’s degree (BA/BS/BBA) or equivalent combination of education and experience.

• 5+ years of casualty claims adjusting experience, including experience with bodily injury, legal liability, and litigation strategy.

• Deep understanding of property, automobile, and casualty policies, insurance principles, and coverage interpretation.

• Proficient in scene investigation, damage analysis, and liability evaluation.

• Strong legal knowledge of Unfair/Fair Claim Practice Acts and Insurance Codes.

• Skilled in preparing coverage letters, damage evaluations, and litigation plans.

• Excellent communication, negotiation, and customer service skills.

• Strong time management and organizational skills.

• Advanced knowledge of MS Excel and general office applications.

• Able to communicate clearly and effectively in writing and verbally.

• Flexible and adaptable to shifting priorities in a fast-paced environment.

• Professional designations (e.g., CPCU, AIC) are a plus.

Why Stillwater?

• Honest, ethical, and supportive team environment

• Clear opportunities for career advancement

• Open communication with leadership

• Individual contributions are recognized and valued

• Work-life balance with strong peer collaboration

Apply today to start your journey of being celebrated and valued with Stillwater Insurance Group.

Offer for employment contingent upon the acceptable responses from both a background investigation and a pre-employment drug screen.

Stillwater Insurance Group is a drug-free workplace and an equal opportunity employer.